05-Sherlock Holmes Mafia Day 5/Endgame

[Xeno]

A question for Volts: when you asked wolty was he Watson, did you already know Croc was?

I found out about it only after the fact but, he might have said yes.
Any killing of a person you asked him to protect would be explained as a Don hit. The game rules were that I had to do all hits while alive (hence my paranoia about being investigated by Threat) but town did not know that.

@Threat: I had deduced from your flipping about on Croc v wolty and your supposedly thoughtful "..." after mentioning you might investigate Rhys that you were planning to investigate me that night; flag waving by saying too much.

I learned a lot from that game.

[Xeno]

One more question if I may, to Rhys. Did you target anyone on the first night when we blocked you, and if so, who?

I considered at the first hit that Rhys had turned SK rather than vig, Durro not seeming like a real SK unless he had also cast a suicide hex, which we did not know. At the time, I was perturbed we had killed durro before he had killed some more townies for us but one of us was on his list anyway

[Sir Patrick Crocodile]

Somebody was sending me PMs throughout the entire game and shattered my whole viewpoint that a PM box will not get full during a Mafia game. Of course that same somebody didn't post a lot during the game and that is how I could pick up that it was possibly scum.

[Rhys]

Originally Posted by Xeno

One more question if I may, to Rhys. Did you target anyone on the first night when we blocked you, and if so, who?

I considered at the first hit that Rhys had turned SK rather than vig, Durro not seeming like a real SK unless he had also cast a suicide hex, which we did not know. At the time, I was perturbed we had killed durro before he had killed some more townies for us but one of us was on his list anyway

No, I didn't attempt to kill anyone the first night. In fact, I wasn't going to kill anybody the second night either, but eventually decided to heed LBA's advice to kill Davo. At that point I was about 70/30 in favour of killing Davo ahead of LP. Third night my decision to try to kill Croc ahead of Wolty was completely arbitrary, I had no basis for it. I trusted Volts and would have felt guilty killing you after all the "help" you had given me , so it was between those two.

[wolty]

Originally Posted by Crocodile

Somebody was sending me PMs throughout the entire game and shattered my whole viewpoint that a PM box will not get full during a Mafia game. Of course that same somebody didn't post a lot during the game and that is how I could pick up that it was possibly scum.

Well obviously that person meant well.

[Rhys]

Originally Posted by Crocodile

Somebody was sending me PMs throughout the entire game and shattered my whole viewpoint that a PM box will not get full during a Mafia game. Of course that same somebody didn't post a lot during the game and that is how I could pick up that it was possibly scum.

I deleted 120 emails from the AFA telling me I had received a new PM this morning .

I knew Wolty was scum after I asked him if he would care to expand after he told me of his suspicious about you and he replied "not really" .

[Sir Patrick Crocodile]

The best bit is the whole situation where first you admitted to me that you tried to kill me, then near the end wolty sent a PM which said something like "did you know Rhys tried to kill you? I know because Volts told me." as if I didn't know that. That was the big giveaway.

[Voltairine]

Originally Posted by Xeno

A question for Volts: when you asked wolty was he Watson, did you already know Croc was?

Hmmm... I wasn't sure but Wolty's answer confirmed him as scum. I felt I had to push Croc a bit for an answer and Wolty's reply encouraged me to push harder.

[Voltairine]

Oh... and "Billy the page"?

[Xeno]

Originally Posted by Voltairine

Oh... and "Billy the page"?

It is a real Holmes character. I gave the wikipedia link in thread. Furthermore, it was the one provided to me by Bol. If you found it hard to believe then that was lack of research, not a problem with the character.


==========================
Pad phantom simulating key drafts