Go Back   AFA Forums > Atheism > Ask an atheist

Ask an atheist Want to know atheists' viewpoints on things? Want to better understand the atheist worldview?
Here's the place.

Reply
 
Thread Tools
  #1  
Old 17th February 2009, 06:38 PM
His Noodly Appendage His Noodly Appendage is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2009
Posts: 99
Default Fun with ethics

Let's start off with my favourite pair of ethical dilemmas...

Trolley:

A runaway train is speeding down the track, and is about to collide with six railway workers doing maintenance on the track. You don't have time or the means to warn them, but right in front of you is the switch to divert the line. If you pull the switch, the train will go down the other track... where one worker is standing. If you do nothing, six will die, if you act, only one will - a net saving of five lives. The one, however, would have survived had you done nothing.

Is it right to pull the switch?

Transplant:

At a hospital, after a terrible storm. The roads are undrivable and the phone lines are down. A tree fell on the building next door, and seven people have been brought in. Six of them have ghastly injuries, each with a different vital organ destroyed, and none are expected to live out the night. The seventh has miraculously escaped all injury except being knocked unconscious - and will be out for the next twelve hours by the look of things. However, by sheer billions-to-one freakish chance, it turns out that he is exactly tissue-compatible with the other six. If you were to organ-harvest the survivor, he would die, but the other six would all survive.

Is it right to go ahead with the transplant?

Do your answers to the two questions differ?

If so, then on what basis?
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 17th February 2009, 07:13 PM
davo's Avatar
davo davo is offline
SIR Vacuous cunt
Administrator
 
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: 3rd Planet from the Sun
Posts: 8,765
Default Re: Fun with ethics

Other than the obvious 'wouldn't the workers see the train' etc etc etc these types of ethical dilemmas are not really accurate, unless you are in the situation. They are fun to talk about tho

I'd just bring out my plank of carneades +3 and float away

The first dilemma is one that I would want more to survive the situation than one, the fact that we could intervene in a situation and save 6 people compared to one.

The second dilemma takes active involvement in the killing someone, to save others, I don't think I could choose that as I couldn't bring myself to do it, the family etc etc, I could be wrong, have no knowledge of medicine so don't know really what can be done just going by the words of others etc etc.

really however, as the situation and all the nuances are not presented, along with the stress of the situation, this is just an interesting mind game
__________________
Spearthrower: "There are words like vacuous & cunt that are applicable."

(delta p)*(delta q) >= h/(4*pi) ----- An explanation of Logical Fallacies : http://www.nizkor.org/features/fallacies ----- ferox deo vacuus vinco ----- How do I post video etc here?
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 17th February 2009, 07:13 PM
eclectic's Avatar
eclectic eclectic is offline
AFA Member. Naked fool.
 
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: Perth, WA
Posts: 702
Default Re: Fun with ethics

I will have to get back to you on this, even though I've done it in ethics class.

My brother is an engineer, and it I love the difference between how my philosophy class responded and his engineering class. We of course took up the dilemma in all seriousness and debated all the different theories and their implications... the engineers didn't get past the first scenario - their answer was "jam the switch in the middle and save everyone."
__________________
Rich in the simple worship of the day. (Keats)
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 17th February 2009, 08:57 PM
His Noodly Appendage His Noodly Appendage is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2009
Posts: 99
Default Re: Fun with ethics

But davo - doesn't pulling a switch to run a train over someone constitute taking an active involvement in killing them?

I mean if you just went and did it without the people on the other track, it would be murder 1...

Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 17th February 2009, 11:03 PM
Godless Ray's Avatar
Godless Ray Godless Ray is offline
AFA Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Blacktown
Posts: 809
Default Re: Fun with ethics

OR... you could do what my little brother did in a real life situation..

fall asleep so someone else has to connect the train when it's connected incorrectly and goes hurtling down a track, chuck a big log under it, derail it, wipe out $50K signal system..phone news paper.. get "heroic save of train" story and citi rail can't fire your ass..

worked for him

Godless Ray
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 17th February 2009, 11:37 PM
SchizoDeluxe's Avatar
SchizoDeluxe SchizoDeluxe is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Perth
Posts: 1,365
Default Re: Fun with ethics

The first I would save the 5, at the end of the day, I could at least say I tried rather than doing nothing or the very least.

The 2nd, I would not kill one person in order to save the others. The difference to this and the first one is subtle but it's there. Unless the person was a willing volunteer to die to save the others, I would not make that decision for that person. Unfortunately, people die in tragic circumstances.

Of course, therés an argument for other solutions and different circumstances, I don't think it's a morality thing as much as it is an instinctive decision but then, doctors probably make these kinds of decisions everyday so who knows.
__________________
I'm completely in favor of the separation of Church and State. My idea is that these two institutions screw us up enough on their own, so both of them together is certain death - George Carlin (R.I.P.)
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 17th February 2009, 11:39 PM
alanqui alanqui is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: North Queensland
Posts: 78
Default Re: Fun with ethics

As stated in Dawkins GD the person on the siding is not being used to save the lives of the five, it is the siding that is being used. Satisfactorily handled as long as you don't read further and compound the thought experiment with more if's.
The same type of thing happened on HMS Ashanti about 30 years ago or more. The engine room caught fire and nearly every one was out so that steam drenching could take place and save the ship. However, there were still a number of sailors still in the engine room and the captain ordered the hatch closed, locked and steam drenching to take place. It saved the ship and remainder of the crew. The thing is, the sailors that had to close the hatch and lock it in place were still there when they heard the knocking on the hatch as the steam drenching took place. Imagine that, would you as one of the sailors have taken the chance, disobeyed orders and opened the hatch and possibly sacrificed the ship and other crew members. Or, would you have let the captain wear the guilt. No, I wasn't there on Ashanti but I received the Mayday.

Last edited by alanqui; 17th February 2009 at 11:48 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 18th February 2009, 01:18 AM
His Noodly Appendage His Noodly Appendage is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Feb 2009
Posts: 99
Default Re: Fun with ethics

Heh. There's a reason I phrased it as 'is it right to do X', as opposed to 'what would you do?'
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 18th February 2009, 09:00 AM
davo's Avatar
davo davo is offline
SIR Vacuous cunt
Administrator
 
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: 3rd Planet from the Sun
Posts: 8,765
Default Re: Fun with ethics

Quote:
His Noodly Appendage said View Post
But davo - doesn't pulling a switch to run a train over someone constitute taking an active involvement in killing them?

I mean if you just went and did it without the people on the other track, it would be murder 1...

Yes, but there are people on the other track, regardless of what the State decides, those would be my actions, as they would be right to me

As I mentioned these 'ethical dilemmas' aren't really so, as they avoid all the nuances of a situation, I played along with the '2 basic choices you have' and what I would do, but in reality I would look for any way to avoid anyone getting hurt, I might even just freeze and freak out. Who knows unless you in that situation? So really, ethical dilemmas presented like this are more games than anything else.

As to what is 'right', as I mentioned, us being social animals, my actions lean toward saving as many as I could from the situation.

The second situation, the right thing for me to do is not try and judge something I don't understand and kill someone for that.
__________________
Spearthrower: "There are words like vacuous & cunt that are applicable."

(delta p)*(delta q) >= h/(4*pi) ----- An explanation of Logical Fallacies : http://www.nizkor.org/features/fallacies ----- ferox deo vacuus vinco ----- How do I post video etc here?
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 18th February 2009, 09:16 AM
davo's Avatar
davo davo is offline
SIR Vacuous cunt
Administrator
 
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: 3rd Planet from the Sun
Posts: 8,765
Default Re: Fun with ethics

Out of interest, and again on a small tangent, the Stanford prison experiment was very interesting, and is what I mean when people can seem, and say, they will do one thing, but can act totally different in a specific situation. It showed the impressionability of people when presented a legitimised ideology. So maybe in fact we act in ethical situations as to what we perceive is right, based on culture and upbringing, or the situational position we stand in when it occurs. Are ethics 'inherent' or a product of our experiences? both I'd say.

__________________
Spearthrower: "There are words like vacuous & cunt that are applicable."

(delta p)*(delta q) >= h/(4*pi) ----- An explanation of Logical Fallacies : http://www.nizkor.org/features/fallacies ----- ferox deo vacuus vinco ----- How do I post video etc here?
Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT +11. The time now is 10:44 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2018, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Feedback Buttons provided by Advanced Post Thanks / Like (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2018 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.