Page 1 of 4 1234 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 37

Thread: Can We Choose to be an Atheist or a Theist

  1. #1
    Join Date
    May 2017
    Location
    Brisbane
    Posts
    78

    Default Can We Choose to be an Atheist or a Theist

    Some posters say they choose to be an atheist or a theist.

    Surely believing in God or Gods is not a choice.

    I see choosing/choice as the issue.

    Juxtapose Unicorn or Unicorns into the above and maybe it might make more sense.

    We can't choose to like ice cream we either like it or not or "take it or leave it".

    Depending on your responses this could be a very meaningful thread, considering some posters choose to meditate and in the medication state they might become a believer.
    God was a giant Queensland Blue Pumpkin. He was lonely and got bored so he blew himself up (aka the big bang) The pumpkin skin fragments became planets, the orange flesh vaporised into gasses and the seed fragments started life when conditions were right.

  2. Like button The Amiable Atheist liked this post
  3. #2
    Join Date
    Aug 2015
    Location
    Melbourne
    Posts
    3,129

    Default Re: Can We Choose to be an Atheist or a Theist

    Are you posing a free will question?

  4. #3
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    Brisbane
    Posts
    24,740

    Default Re: Can We Choose to be an Atheist or a Theist

    You can't choose to believe something.

    I've mostly heard this from Theists, that Atheists choose 'not' to believe.
    Theists intimate that Atheists believe in 'God' but pretend or choose not to.
    .
    .
    .


    The Nizkor Project- Logical Fallacies

    Atheist: n; A person to be pitied in that he is unable to believe things for which there is no evidence, and who has thus deprived himself of a convenient means of feeling superior to others.
    —Chaz Bufe, The American Heretic’s Dictionary

  5. #4
    Join Date
    Aug 2010
    Location
    Kilmore
    Posts
    2,911

    Default Re: Can We Choose to be an Atheist or a Theist

    You can choose to be dick or not to be a dick, but choosing to believe or not believe is a bit more difficult, but who knows what goes on in the mind of a theist that has had to opportunity to evaluate the overwhelming lack of evidence for a deity.
    The meaning of your life, is what you choose to make it.

  6. #5
    Loki's Avatar
    Loki is offline You get what everyone gets....you get a lifetime Moderator
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Location
    Up the creek
    Posts
    11,177

    Default Re: Can We Choose to be an Atheist or a Theist

    Quote wolty said View Post
    You can't choose to believe something.

    I've mostly heard this from Theists, that Atheists choose 'not' to believe.
    Theists intimate that Atheists believe in 'God' but pretend or choose not to.
    I don't think the "it's not a choice" answer is either useful or relevant.

    My conclusion with regards gods is a consequence of my choices, not a choice or non-choice in itself.

    By my "choices" i mean my choices to be curious, to question, to seek understanding, to sample all the available information and follow wherever it may lead.

    Of course the religious will contend they make the same choices. I disagree.
    "Reality is that which, when you stop believing in it, doesn't go away."Philip K. Dick


  7. Like button wolty, Voltairine, Blue Lightning liked this post
  8. #6
    Join Date
    Aug 2011
    Location
    The Cotswolds, UK
    Posts
    688

    Default Re: Can We Choose to be an Atheist or a Theist

    Indeed Warty, some theists posit belief in their nominated deity as a default, intrinsic state which 'sinners' choose to abandon or reject.

    However, I think 'belief' is the wrong term to apply to this particular question, which restated might be something like: Can we choose to accept or reject evidenced or unevidenced claims and assertions?

    This, I think, highlights that some kinds of political (small p) choices are made without reference to the truth status of a proposition, and the enquiry then turns to revealing the reasons for those choices independently of the facts of the matter.

    Of course, we could easily get bogged down here, and we should probably acknowledge that one choice can, and often does, impact on many subsequent choices.

    For example, the person who has arrived at the decision to withhold assent for all unevidenced claims will certainly be an atheist in circumstances where a belief in god-claims does not have to be, and generally is not, even approached.
    ...never eat your own nose...

  9. Like button wolty, Loki, MarkFL, Voltairine, Stubby and 2 others liked this post
  10. #7
    Join Date
    May 2017
    Location
    St. Augustine, FL., U.S.
    Posts
    67

    Default Re: Can We Choose to be an Atheist or a Theist

    Quote THWOTH said View Post
    Indeed Warty, some theists posit belief in their nominated deity as a default, intrinsic state which 'sinners' choose to abandon or reject.
    Yes, I have heard things like "What dire event in your life caused you to reject the wondrous gift of the Jeebus? or "Why do you hate gAWWWd?" implying that deep down I must "know" their sky-daddy exists, but I choose to rock the boat and act like I deny this "undeniable truth."

    Quote THWOTH said View Post
    However, I think 'belief' is the wrong term to apply to this particular question, which restated might be something like: Can we choose to accept or reject evidenced or unevidenced claims and assertions?
    Yes, exactly this.

    Quote THWOTH said View Post
    This, I think, highlights that some kinds of political (small p) choices are made without reference to the truth status of a proposition, and the enquiry then turns to revealing the reasons for those choices independently of the facts of the matter.
    This is how my atheism came about...I realized I simply cannot believe anything without sufficient reason to do so. I didn't see it as a choice, but rather a realization of my skeptic nature.

    Quote THWOTH said View Post
    Of course, we could easily get bogged down here, and we should probably acknowledge that one choice can, and often does, impact on many subsequent choices.
    This is one of the things I bring up to people who ask, "What harm is there to simply leave the deluded theist to have his beliefs, if they give him comfort/hope, etc.?"

    Of course there's the more important issue of many theists not being content to keep their delusions private, and trying to impose them on others, but that's for another thread.

    Quote THWOTH said View Post
    For example, the person who has arrived at the decision to withhold assent for all unevidenced claims will certainly be an atheist in circumstances where a belief in god-claims does not have to be, and generally is not, even approached.
    Indeed.I suspect most people behave as if there is no god/gods except for a few choice issues.
    Living in the pools, They soon forget about the sea...— Rush, "Natural Science" (1980)

  11. #8
    Join Date
    May 2017
    Location
    Brisbane
    Posts
    78

    Default Re: Can We Choose to be an Atheist or a Theist

    Quote pipbarber said View Post
    Are you posing a free will question?
    My question could be described as not in the freewill arena but more in the self deceit arena.

    Some people, or so it seems to me, offer excuses for doing things they want to do. Excuses start with the kiddies after doing something "wrong" trying to get out of trouble with their parents.

    "Me bruvver done it first."

    But my "excuses" analogy my be unwarranted i have not given it a lot of thought.
    God was a giant Queensland Blue Pumpkin. He was lonely and got bored so he blew himself up (aka the big bang) The pumpkin skin fragments became planets, the orange flesh vaporised into gasses and the seed fragments started life when conditions were right.

  12. #9
    Join Date
    Feb 2013
    Posts
    325

    Default Re: Can We Choose to be an Atheist or a Theist

    The only way I think you can choose to believe is if you suffer from anterograde amnesia and tattoo "god is real" on yourself.

  13. #10
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Location
    Toontown, in the Bible Belt.
    Posts
    7,380

    Default Re: Can We Choose to be an Atheist or a Theist

    Quote Madame Tarot said View Post
    Some posters say they choose to be an atheist or a theist.

    Surely believing in God or Gods is not a choice.

    I see choosing/choice as the issue.

    Juxtapose Unicorn or Unicorns into the above and maybe it might make more sense.

    We can't choose to like ice cream we either like it or not or "take it or leave it".

    Depending on your responses this could be a very meaningful thread, considering some posters choose to meditate and in the medication state they might become a believer.
    What's the reasoning behind the orange writing? Meditation is sitting, thinking, or not-thinking, and there is no obvious tie-in with belief, by choice or otherwise, is there?
    EJB

    I’m not one of the dead ones yet. - Ms Fishie.


  14. Thank button knowledge is power thanked this post

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •